Can you believe I’m back with another post already? I’m on a roll, my dudes 🛼 (for those of you that have been watching season 4 of Stranger Things, you’ll get the other reference to this emoji too 😂). Today I’ll be looking at the top 10 best books I’ve read according to Goodreads and sharing my thoughts on each.
I did a similar post when I did the ‘Goodreads was Wrong’ tag last year, but I thought it would be fun to do a follow up comparing what I perceive to be the best books I’ve read with how they’ve been rated by others on Goodreads. It’s particularly fun because I typically tend to go against the grain a lot with how I feel about a book versus how the general population does 😂 I’m genuinely intrigued to see which books will come out on top 😝
The post is inspired by Regan at PeruseProject on YouTube who made a video on this topic. Credit for the original idea goes to Hailey in Bookland on YouTube.
Disclaimers:
- I won’t be including any Harry Potter books on this list because they obviously are always rated extremely high.
- I also won’t be including any Lord of the Rings books for the exact same reason.
- Where multiple books from a series are included in the top 10, I’ll be bunching them together and including them as one.
With disclaimers done let’s get into the top 10 best books that I’ve read according to Goodreads starting with the one that came out in tenth spot.
10. The Sword of Kaigen – M. L. Wang
Fantasy readers will have no doubt have heard of this Japanese inspired high fantasy stand-alone. It gained a lot of popularity in online book communities and has been highly praised. The challenge with a standalone high fantasy book is that there’s limited space to fully flesh out the magic system, world-building, characters and plot. There’s a whole lot more that goes into high-fantasy which is why so many of these stories are often book series. Despite that, M. L. Wang does a fantastic job here of being able to craft such a believable world, complex characters and a gripping plot.
On a personal level, I didn’t enjoy it as much as I expected to but this book is absolutely worth its merit. In terms of fantasy standalone’s it sticks out in my mind as being one of the best written ones I’ve come across. The protagonist Misaki is one of my favourite female leads I’ve read in fantasy. Her perspective as an older woman with children was so refreshing since fantasy is often from the perspective of younger characters or male characters. There are also some truly memorable moments from this book that will always be present in my mind. Although I wouldn’t personally class it as being one of the best books I’ve ever read it’s deserving of its place here.
9. The Final Empire – Brandon Sanderson
Another popular fantasy book with the first from the Mistborn series. This series (and pretty much every Sanderson series for that matter) is included on almost every “best of” fantasy lists so it’s not surprising that it’s made it into the top 10 here. The Final Empire is a very entertaining read with a cool and unique magic system. I really liked the protagonist Vin and the world-building.
Unfortunately, I just don’t see the hype with this series and this book fell completely flat for me. In terms of writing style, Sanderson is not my cup of tea. Although he has incredible ideas his execution leaves something to be desired. His writing is so clunky and clumsy that it pulls me out of the story. Despite popular opinion, I’d say this is far from one of the best books I’ve read, even as far as fantasy goes it’s pretty far down the list.
8. In the Dream House – Carmen Maria Machado
Read the full review here.
I wasn’t expecting to see this one here but I’m so happy that it is. This autobiography explores the authors experiences of domestic abuse in her relationship with her ex-girlfriend. The narration style is so unique and other-worldly but works incredibly as a tool for exploring domestic abuse through the lens of queerness and feminism. Machado’s voice shines through so strongly and her personal experience and perspective offers so much value to this topic. It provides so much insight into domestic abuse from an intersectional perspective centring sexual orientation, gender, race and culture within the wider framework of domestic abuse research.
Although this is an autobiography, it reads like a story, immersing the reader into the twisty-turvy of the Machado’s inner world. I found it to be a very impactful and awe-inspiring, and it was by far one of my favourite reads of 2021. It’s without a doubt worthy and deserving of being included in this list and I’m so happy to see that a book like this has also been highly rated by other readers.
7. The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo – Taylor Jenkins Reid
Read full review here.
No surprise this is here. I feel like most readers have read it or have at the least heard of it. I love this book, it’s one of my favourites. The 1950s Hollywood vibes are just *chefs kiss* and I love the way that Taylor Jenkins Reid is able to create drama that I thrive on. I was also pleasantly caught off-guard with the depiction of bisexuality (read my post ‘Queerness and Bisexuality: The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo here) and loved how it completely subverted all my expectations on my first read.
Unfortunately, like any book that explodes in popularity and is so well-loved it runs the risk of becoming overrated. I’m sure many do think it’s overrated but me? Never. I think it’s an absolutely wonderful book and deserving of all of the love it receives. I’ve read it twice and loved it as much the second time as I did the first. If I was composing my own personal list of best ever reads, The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo would probably be on there so it’s quite fitting that it’s here.
6. The Heart’s Invisible Furies
I really didn’t expect this to make the top 10 so I’m absolutely delighted it’s made it to the sixth spot 🥳 This literary novel follows the trials and tribulations of Cyril a gay man born in Ireland in the 1940s. Spanning decades and multiple generations, this is a heavy and emotional story that uncovers the trauma Cyril endures as a result of his sexuality and wider issues in the LGBTQ community such as the AIDs epidemic of the 1980s.
I absolutely loved this book. It was one of my favourite reads of 2021 and hit almost everything I look for in a book in terms of character work, plot, themes and writing style. I love books that explore dark, emotional themes and act as intense character study into the protagonist’s internal and external world. And that’s exactly what this book is. It’s a powerful story and an example of groundbreaking literature. I’d go as far as to call it a masterpiece. So without a doubt it deserves to be on this list and again, if I was making my own list this would definitely be featured.
5. The Hate U Give – Angie Thomas
The Hate U Give has gained so much traction in the book community and also with mainstream readers, particularly since Black Lives Matter. Since then it’s been added to the school curriculum in many schools in the UK, exposing it to wider audiences of young people. The story follows Starr a young black girl who witnesses the shooting of a friend by the police at the start of the book. What follows is an exploration of Starr’s family and community as they deal with this tragedy and stand against injustice.
This is one hell of a powerful book that provides insight into such a deeply traumatising but very real evil that exists in our society. It explores racism through the eyes of a young teenager, making it accessible for other teenagers. Starr’s family are so well crafted and the dynamics between them feel very authentic. Similarly, Starr’s struggles and emotions are very relatable. Personally, I didn’t feel I was the target audience of this book reading it as an adult in my late 20s so wouldn’t necessarily include it in my best reads (particularly because I feel I’ve read other books that explore similar themes better), but the value and impact of this book cannot be understated, especially for younger audiences.
4. Hollowpox: The Hunt for Morrigan Crow – Jessica Townsend
This is the third book in the middle-grade fantasy series Nevermoor. It follows the adventures of Morrigan Crow, an 11 year old girl who is transported to the magical world of Nevermoor. The series has been compared to Harry Potter (which middle-grade/YA fantasy isn’t?) but this one genuinely does give Harry Potter vibes. The only catch is that Nevermoor is so much better. In terms of characters, world-building, plot, entertainment, writing style, it’s all done so well and comes together with an amazing end result. Being the third book in the series, Hollowpox steps it up in terms of the stakes, plot and character development. It also has the advantage of telling a story about a pandemic released at a time when we were all living through a global pandemic, making it extra relevant and relatable.
Nevermoor is one of my favourite fantasy series I’ve read in a long time and Hollowpox has been the strongest instalment in the series so far, so I feel it’s deserving of a spot on this list. In terms of new fantasy series that have been released in recent years, it stands out as being one of the best and for the younger generations, this genuinely has the potential to become what Harry Potter was for millennials like myself.
3. McFly: Unsaid Things – McFly
Well…I guess I’ve outed myself now: yes, I am a McFly fan 🤣 growing up, I was McFly obsessed. I read this as a young teen and it’s actually one of the first books I marked as read on Goodreads. To date, it’s the only autobiography McFly have released and it provides an intimate into their lives as individuals and as a band with alternating sections written by each of the band members. It’s a very honest account of the personal issues and struggles the guys have had but it suffers the same issues any autobiography written by multiple people does of lacking flow and feeling very choppy. In terms of literary merit, this obviously doesn’t constitute as a best read and shouldn’t be on this list, but as a McFly obsessed teenager, it came pretty close 😂
2. Kingdom of Ash & Empire of Storms – Sarah J. Maas
These are books seven (Kingdom of Ash) and five (Empire of Storms) in the popular YA/NA fantasy series Throne of Glass. Again, this series is one of those that you’ve probably heard of even if you haven’t read the books yourself. I was introduced to this series through a buddy read I did with friends. It was in the early days of my getting back into reading and fantasy, and this binge-worthy and entertaining series sucked me in.
Ironically, these two books specifically were two of my least favourites in the series. My Goodreads review for Empire of Storms was a rant about everything in the book that frustrated me and my review for Kingdom of Ash was summed up as being a major disappointment 😂
These books do deliver high entertainment value for readers that enjoy fantasy romance, drama and action, but in terms of best reads I definitely wouldn’t include it on this list. Like The Final Empire this popular fantasy series just isn’t for me personally.
1. Heartstopper Vol.4, Vol.3 & Vol.2 – Alice Oseman
Not one, not two but THREE of the Hearstopper comics made it into first place. With the Netflix series recently being released, I’d imagine there’s been an influx of people reading Heartstopper and falling in love with it but even prior to the series release, it was a very well-loved series. For the benefit of the few that haven’t heard of Heartstopper, it follows two characters – Charlie and Nick – and the evolution of their relationship and self-growth. It’s a heartwarming LGBTQ story that has made a lot of people feel seen and safe.
I’ve read all volumes in the series and really enjoyed them. The storytelling is beautiful and Alice Oseman has done something so refreshing with this series by creating a positive and uplifting queer story. Too often queer stories focus on trauma and whilst that might be representative of the lived experiences of a lot of queer people, we also want happy stories just like anybody else. So I’m happy this series is on the list although I definitely wouldn’t have given it top spot.
There we have it – the best books I’ve read according to Goodreads! That was fun 😄
Surprisingly, I agreed with a lot of these books being on the list. Books like The Heart’s Invisible Furies and In the Dream House were pleasant surprises for me because they’re not the type of books I’d expect to be popular with wider readers but books that I’d definitely consider to be two of the best I’ve ever read. Other books were pretty predictable and ironically, those ones that are super popular are the ones I probably wouldn’t have included on my personal list 😅
Do you know what Goodreads considers to be the best books you’ve ever read? Have a look and see, and let me know your results in the comments!
Stay safe, my lovelies and keep reading.